Moving home is an exciting new chapter, but packing can quickly become overwhelming, especially when deciding between cardboard boxes and plastic totes. Which one is better? The answer depends on your budget, move type, and long-term needs. At Going Places Removals, we’ve helped hundreds of families move safely and efficiently, and we’re here to guide you through the pros and cons of boxes vs totes so you can pack smart and move stress-free.
Why Choose Boxes for Moving?
The Tried-and-True Cardboard Box
Cardboard boxes have been the go-to choice for moving for decades. They’re affordable, lightweight, and easy to handle. Most importantly, they’re accessible—you can find them everywhere, from supermarkets and warehouses to online shops and recycling centres.
Affordability That Suits Every Budget
One of the biggest advantages of cardboard boxes is their low cost. If you’re looking to keep moving expenses down, cardboard is a smart option. You can often find them for free at local shops or buy them in bulk for very little. For single-use purposes, especially during short-distance moves, boxes are a clear winner.
Size Variety for Every Item
Boxes come in all shapes and sizes. Small boxes are ideal for books or fragile items, while larger boxes can hold bedding, clothes, or toys. You can even get specialised boxes like wardrobe boxes that allow you to hang clothes straight from your wardrobe into the box, saving you from ironing later.
Easy Labelling for Quick Unpacking
A permanent marker and some tape are all you need to label your boxes. This helps you stay organised and makes unpacking easier. Write the room and contents on the top and sides so you can spot it quickly, no matter how it’s stacked.
Environmentally Friendly Choices
Many cardboard boxes are made from recycled materials. After your move, you can reuse them, give them away, or recycle them. If sustainability is important to you, look for boxes that are FSC-certified or made with post-consumer waste.
Downsides of Cardboard Boxes
Despite their popularity, boxes aren’t perfect for every situation. They’re more fragile than totes and can be crushed or torn if overfilled. Exposure to moisture can also weaken the cardboard, putting your items at risk. Packing boxes also takes more time—you need to assemble them with tape and reinforce the bottom before use.
The Rise of Plastic Totes
Plastic totes are becoming more popular among movers, especially for people planning long-distance moves or needing long-term storage. They are durable, reusable, and secure—all major advantages when handling valuables or sensitive items.
Strong and Long-Lasting
Unlike cardboard, plastic totes are waterproof, tear-resistant, and much stronger. If you’re moving in bad weather or have fragile electronics or glassware, a tote offers better protection. They also stack well, which helps maximise space in a moving van or storage unit.
Reusable and Eco-Smart
Though totes cost more initially, they’re a smart investment for future moves or household storage. Use them in your attic, garage, or shed to organise decorations, tools, or seasonal clothes. This long-term reusability makes them more environmentally friendly than you might expect.
Quick to Pack with Built-In Lids
Most totes come with clip-on or attached lids, which means no need for tape. This speeds up the packing process and gives you a cleaner, more professional-looking move. Some people also prefer the uniform appearance of totes when organising a large-scale move.
Best for Business or Long-Distance Moves
If you’re relocating your home office or moving to another city, totes offer extra peace of mind. You won’t have to worry about collapsing boxes or soggy cardboard. Everything stays safe, dry, and intact.
Downsides of Totes
Despite their many benefits, totes aren’t right for everyone. The upfront cost is higher than cardboard, especially if you’re buying a large number. While they’re a good investment over time, they may not suit short-term or one-time movers. Totes also tend to come in fewer sizes, which can make it hard to pack large or oddly shaped items.
Key Things to Consider
Choosing between boxes and totes comes down to a few important factors. Let’s take a look at the key points you should consider before deciding.
1. Budget
If keeping costs low is a priority, cardboard boxes are clearly the cheaper choice. But if you’re planning to move again or need durable storage, totes may be worth the investment. Think of totes as a long-term solution rather than a one-off cost.
2. Move Distance and Conditions
For local moves on a dry day, cardboard boxes are usually fine. But for long-distance or international moves, or if you’re expecting rain, totes provide far more protection. If you’re moving expensive electronics or sentimental valuables, that added security is worth it.
3. Storage Needs
Planning to store items after the move? Plastic totes are perfect for attics, basements, and garages. Their sealable lids keep out dust and moisture, and they stack beautifully. On the other hand, cardboard boxes are better for quick unpacking or short-term storage needs.
4. Environmental Impact
Want to stay green? Both boxes and totes have eco-friendly options. Choose recycled boxes or reuse old ones from friends or local businesses. Or go for reusable totes you can keep using for years. Avoid single-use plastic containers, and recycle packing materials where possible.
How to Use Both Boxes and Totes Together
You don’t have to choose just one—most people benefit from using a mix of both. Here’s how to combine them effectively:
-
Use boxes for lightweight or bulky items like bedding, clothes, or kitchen utensils.
-
Reserve totes for fragile, valuable, or heavy items, such as books, electronics, or ceramics.
-
Label everything clearly, whether it’s a box or tote, with the destination room and a short item list.
-
Stack heavier totes at the bottom and lighter cardboard boxes on top to avoid squashing.
Don’t Want to Pack Yourself?
No problem! At Going Places Removals, we offer full and partial packing services. Our trained team knows how to handle everything from delicate antiques to everyday kitchenware. We use the right materials—whether boxes or totes—to keep your belongings secure.
We also offer eco-friendly moving options, including reusable tote hire, recycled boxes, and waste collection after the move.
Why Choose Going Places Removals?
We know that no two moves are the same. Whether you’re moving to your first flat, upgrading to a bigger house, or downsizing for retirement, we’re here to help. With years of experience, top-rated packing materials, and friendly, skilled movers, Going Places Removals makes moving easier.
-
Free, no-obligation quotes tailored to your move
-
Flexible packing options to suit your schedule and budget
-
Safe, reliable transport for all your belongings
-
Sustainable moving practices to protect the planet
Ready to Move? Let’s Get Started!
So, is it better to move with boxes or totes? The answer depends on what matters most to you—budget, convenience, storage, or sustainability.
At Going Places Removals, we can provide the right packing materials for your move, offer expert advice, and even do the packing for you. Contact us today for a free quote, and let us help you start your next chapter with ease.
Find Top-Quality Moving Services with Going Places Removals Near You
